brother in law's stroke

Just to clarify, my brother in law recently had a stroke and he:

• was not old and fat
• disclaims any knowledge of Shimon Peres
• Couldn't have been bribed even if he wanted to be
• did not give away the land of Israel
• was not hit by any pulsa denora.

Even with all of that, I would not dare to suggest that it was a medical accident. It is obviously part of God's greater plan. We may never know the reason why he and his family (and mine) are suffering like this, but I would say that calling it an accident desecrates the natural workings of the world.